Emotional Agility > Toxic Positivity: Learn to Feel Without Faking It

Emotional Agility > Toxic Positivity: Learn to Feel Without Faking It
Published
Written by
Dr. Liana Cole

With a PhD in Psychology and a personal history of burnout, I believe wellness starts from within—mentally, emotionally, and yes, even spiritually. I combine evidence-based practices with lived experience to explore emotional resilience, self-regulation, and the kind of mindset shifts that actually stick. Think of me as your science-backed, therapy-adjacent friend who’s not afraid to get real about life’s mental load.

Hello, dear reader. Picture this: you're having a less-than-stellar day, and you voice your frustration to a friend. Instead of offering a listening ear, they respond with, "Just think positive." Sounds familiar, right? This well-intentioned advice can often feel dismissive, adding a layer of guilt or shame for feeling anything less than happy. This is where emotional agility comes into play, and I'm excited to take you on this journey to explore its significance over toxic positivity.

1. Understanding Emotional Agility

On a not-so-sunny day a few years back, I found myself engulfed in a whirlwind of emotions from personal and professional setbacks. Desperate, I turned to the myriad of positivity mantras plastered on social media, only to feel even more disconnected. It was then that I stumbled upon the concept of emotional agility, and it felt like a breath of fresh air.

What is Emotional Agility?

Emotional agility, a term coined by psychologist Susan David, refers to the ability to navigate life's twists and turns with self-acceptance and grace. It's about embracing the full spectrum of our emotions—anger, sadness, joy, and everything in between—without judgment. This approach empowers us to live authentically and respond effectively to life's challenges.

Why Toxic Positivity Doesn't Work

Toxic positivity, on the other hand, insists on the relentless pursuit of happiness while rejecting any negative emotion. While optimism is a wonderful trait, ignoring or denying genuine feelings can lead to a disconnect with oneself and hinder personal growth. Emotional agility allows us to acknowledge our true emotions, offering a more nuanced and honest way of dealing with our inner world.

2. The Science Behind Emotions

As someone who has spent considerable time researching wellness, I find the science of emotions endlessly fascinating. Emotions are not just fleeting states; they're essential data points that guide our decision-making, signal our values, and inform us about our needs.

The Biology of Emotions

Our brain, particularly the limbic system, plays a critical role in processing emotions. According to Psychology Today [link], emotions like fear trigger the "fight or flight" response, an evolutionary mechanism that prepares us for danger. Similarly, happiness releases dopamine and serotonin, the "feel-good" chemicals that promote well-being.

Emotions as Information

When we treat emotions as data rather than directives, we gain invaluable insights into our internal landscape. For example, feeling anxious before a presentation might indicate the need for better preparation or a change in approach. By acknowledging and dissecting our emotions, we can make informed, intentional choices.

3. Navigating Emotional Agility in Real Life

Drawing from personal experience, here are practical steps for fostering emotional agility, enriched by moments from my own journey.

Acknowledge Your Emotions

The first step is to recognize and label your emotions without judgment. In a journal, I've found solace by simply writing phrases like, "I'm feeling overwhelmed." Naming emotions can diminish their intensity and provide clarity.

Accept and Embrace

In the midst of a career change last year, fear and self-doubt were constant companions. Instead of forcing positivity, I learned to sit with these feelings, acknowledging their presence as natural responses to an uncertain situation. Acceptance doesn't mean resignation—it means creating space for growth.

Implement Mindful Practices

Mindfulness has been a game-changer for me. Techniques like deep breathing and body scanning help me stay grounded in the present moment, reducing emotional reactivity. These practices allow space for reflection and response, rather than impulsive reactions.

Align Actions with Values

One of the transformative aspects of emotional agility is aligning actions with values. By understanding what truly matters, we can prioritize actions that resonate with our core beliefs. For me, this meant pivoting careers toward work that aligns with my passion for wellness, despite the initial fear.

4. Addressing Common Misconceptions

It’s crucial to address the common misunderstandings about emotional agility and toxic positivity, ensuring clarity and dismantling myths.

Myth: Emotional Agility Means Overindulging in Emotions

Some might mistake emotional agility for wallowing in emotions. But the opposite is true. It's about recognizing feelings, understanding their root causes, and using them to inform decisions rather than becoming stuck.

Myth: Positivity is Always Good

While positivity is beneficial, it's not a panacea. Ignoring negative feelings can prevent healing and authentic connections. Studies show that acknowledging a range of emotions can lead to better psychological health.

Myth: Emotional Agility is Inflexible

Emotional agility is not about choosing between two extremes. It’s a dynamic practice that involves flexibility in thoughts and behaviors, adapting to each unique situation.

5. Cultivating Emotional Agility in Relationships

Emotional agility doesn't just benefit ourselves; it transforms our relationships too.

Communicating With Agility

I've learned the value of open, honest communication in relationships. Sharing emotions honestly, using "I" statements, and actively listening helps build trust and understanding.

Navigating Conflicts

In conflicts, emotional agility encourages addressing underlying emotions rather than surface-level triggers. Reflecting on the emotions involved can lead to more productive and compassionate resolutions.

Encouraging Emotional Agility in Others

By modeling emotional agility, we can inspire those around us. Encouraging others to express their emotions and providing a safe space for vulnerability cultivates stronger, more authentic connections.

Conclusion: Embrace the Journey

Emotional agility is a lifelong journey—a skill we nurture over time. It's about embracing each emotional experience with curiosity and compassion, allowing us to lead fuller, more authentic lives. By letting go of the need for constant positivity, we open ourselves to a richer human experience, where every emotion is an opportunity for insight and growth.

Your Plus Points!

  1. Name it to tame it: Recognize and label your feelings without judgment.
  2. Embrace the whole: Accept both joyful and challenging emotions as part of life’s journey.
  3. Mindfulness matters: Try a daily mindfulness practice, like deep breathing or meditation, to stay grounded.
  4. Values guide actions: Reflect on what truly matters and align your actions accordingly.
  5. Open, honest communication: Use "I" statements to express emotions, fostering understanding in relationships.

These insights offer a starting point for integrating emotional agility into your everyday life—because embracing our authentic selves is a gentle way of adding wellness to every day.


Remember, emotional agility is not about perfection; it's about progress, curiosity, and a deeper connection with our emotional selves. As you journey onward, know you're not alone, and every feeling is a step toward growth.

Was this article helpful? Let us know!